Jump to content

Changes are(n't) Coming (for now) (Updated January 2022)


Recommended Posts

UPDATE 1/23/22: A quick word on what's going on here:

 

These plans were made leading up to 2020, and were set to be implemented partway through that year, with a public announcement being made in May. However, the ongoing effects of the COVID-19 pandemic put a stop to them. As the pandemic drew out, I did not believe it was worth imposing a major change on the way the site functions, nor did I personally have the "spoons" to implement such changes. They were indefinitely placed on hold, albeit without much of an announcement (which was a mistake that I will own up to) while patiently waiting and hoping that the pandemic would reach some sort of conclusion that some were leading us on to believe.

 

Over the past two years, it has become apparent that the way the internet works, as well as the direction the local TV industry is heading, requires a more in-depth look at how this site functions and what it offers to the community, going beyond some surface-level changes like were proposed below. Some time back, several members of our community started a Discord server that we went on to officially sponsor. That server's popularity has grown immensely over the past two years. However, the problem that has created is a disconnect from the Forum community, and duplication of content and discussion.

 

This is just a result of the way the internet is evolving. Forums such as these are "old" internet, they grew out of the early internet BBS communities, a concept invented in the 1970's. Today, real-time communication, such as Discord, dominates the world of internet communities. 

 

So, what now? Over the past year or so, I have been exploring ways to try and unify these two services so nobody misses out on the goings-on in one of these two separate services. This will not happen easily, and will require both backend and user-facing changes to how the functions and looks. These things do not come easily, and progress on it is still very much in the exploratory phase.

 

In addition, I want to ensure any change preserves the rich history of this forum, as well as expand on the purpose this site serves. The forum alone has 15 years of history recorded on it, and many of our members have put in countless hours into research that also deserves to be chronicled.  To that end, any changes should also allow for the preservation of this information, which is often not considered important enough to be placed on other platforms, such as Wikipedia. How this would function is, again, very much in an exploratory phase. I also want the site to be able to showcase the various projects that members of our community have started up,  including blogs and podcasts.

 

I want to stress that this does not mean the Forum is considered "dead" or a lower priority. It will continue to exist and function as-is for the foreseeable future. At some point, maybe even soon, I might revisit these proposed changes and decide to implement them as a way to segue the site into its next chapter. If and when that happens, it'll be posted in this board.

 

-Weeters

 

Previous post archived below:
 

Spoiler

A while back we held a poll regarding "general" threads - threads with a loose topic, meant to keep random tidbits from ending up in improper threads - and the overall consensus was that it was time for them to go. This update is about that. Please note that general threads will not go away entirely. Some threads may remain (such as the Classic Video threads) and new threads will be created (such as a "Comings and Goings" thread to replace "Out and About".)

 

Threads that will be closed under the new rules will be flagged prior to these changes being made, to allow conversations to be split off into new threads.

 

Forum Changes:
To encourage better, more focused conversations, there will be some changes made regarding the overall layout of the boards. New boards will be added, and some boards will be merged or removed. While the industry has changed a lot since the TVNewsTalk Forum signed on in the early 2000's, the forum has not. These changes will be put into place later on, and a site announcement will be made prior to the changes being implemented, as the site will be briefly unavailable while they are made.

 

The new board layout will be:

  • TVNewsTalk.net (Category)
    • Site Announcements
  • General TV (Category)
    • TV Industry Discussion (Currently "General TV" but refocused on the industry overall. Local station specifics moved to Regional boards below)
    • "Corporate Chat" depreciated, merged with Industry Discussion
    • Digital News Discussion (Web/Mobile/Social Discussion. "Social Media" renamed and relocated from "Communications Center" Category.)
  • Local News (Category, regions based off this map.)
    • Northeast
      • NYC Board - Remains, but Station General sub-forum depreciated.
      • Philadelphia Board depreciated due to lack of use, merged with Northeast region
    • South
    • Midwest
      • Chicago Board - Remains
    • West
      • Los Angeles Board depreciated due to lack of use, merged with West region
  • National and International News (Category)
    • US National News (US Cable News and National News merged together)
    • International News
    • Sportscasting (Current "Sport Center" Board, refocused on sports broadcasting. Originally intended for just discussion of sports, it's more or less become about sports broadcasting)
  • General Topics (Category)
    • On-Air Appearance (Merging Graphics/Music/Sets boards into one, since standardization has become so prevalent they're almost always cross-posts) 
    • Engineering and Tech
    • Research (Current "Classic Video" and "Tape Library" merged. Focus on researching different topics and sharing of classic video and articles.)
    • "Weather Lab" depreciated, moved to TV Industry Discussion
  • Everything Else (Category)
    • Breakroom
    • Speculation
    • Graphics Dept.
    • Test Board

 

Guidelines Changes:

Changes will be made to the site's Guidelines to enforce the new purpose of any remaining general threads.

  • (New) Topics should be as focused as possible. Topics should be thought of as a conversation on a specific subject. Creation of catch-all "general" threads that bounce between subjects is no longer permitted without administrator approval.
  • (Modified) Content should not be disruptive to the flow of conversation. Consider the subject of the topic you are posting in. Posts that are irrelevant to the topic at hand belong in either a different or new topic. Additionally, posting low-quality, one line posts and responses (e.g. "I agree!" "Yeah." "Is it done yet?") disrupts the flow of conversation and adds nothing constructive.  Excessive use of capital letters (TYPING IN ALL CAPS) is not allowed. Nonsensical posts and posts that do not follow the basic rules of the English language are likely to be removed. 
  • (New) Content should be posted in a calm and respectful manner. While you may disagree with another users opinion, or the way certain stations or companies are run, constantly bringing up your disagreement with them, or ranting about them, is frowned upon. You are free to express your opinions, just do so in a calm manner that is respectful of the people who's daily lives are actually impacted by the issue at hand. There are real people behind all of these decisions, and many of them care as much about TV News as any news fan does.  

 

 

FAQ and Examples:

There will obviously be many questions regarding the roll out of these changes. We expect the biggest question will simply be "Why?"

 

One of the biggest complaints we get from casual site users is that it has become increasingly difficult to find things on TVNT. Conversations are broken up between numerous threads. Posts about a single Tegna station's graphics are in the Tegna corporate thread. Graphics discussion about one station ends up in the Sets and Studios thread for the set they launched at the same time. New cuts of music are discussed in a station-specific thread. Discussion about a possible company merger are buried inside the company's general thread between posts about a single station's anchor retiring or complaints about music. This fracturing of information makes it hard to jump into the conversation and leads to disruption in other threads where someone will be told "We're already talking about that over here."

 

Moving forward, general-type threads may be only used for the following:

  • Talent and Staff Moves/Retirements/Etc. - A new "Comings and Goings" thread will be created in "TV Industry Discussion" for lower profile moves/retirements/etc. Higher profile situations, such as a main anchor in a large market station, are expected to go in their own thread in their appropriate region.
  • Company-wide initiatives - We do not expect you to create a new thread for every station that debuts a company graphics package. It is okay to have a "Scripps v.3 Graphics" thread, as long as the conversation is about the package as a whole. A station debuting a new logo with the graphics launch would warrant its own thread.
  • Industry-wide happenings - A  thread discussing stations rolling out ATSC 3.0 is fine, as long as the conversation is about the rollout overall. A single station doing something (i.e. WXXX debuting an ATSC 3.0-compliant weather alert ticker or experimenting with 4K transmission) should go in its own thread.

 

We are sure there will be more questions that come up about these changes. That is why we are holding off implementing them. We expect to begin this process in mid-June, once we work through any feedback or complications that may arise. 

 

Please feel free to leave your questions below!

 

 

  • Thanks 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On the region thing would there be away to specify which states are listed in each of the regions?

 

I ask that because if say were talking about a TV station in say Oklahoma I want to be sure I'm posting in the right area and not posting it in say the Midwest region only to find out it belongs in the south region and vise versa.

 

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, oknewsguy said:

On the region thing would there be away to specify which states are listed in each of the regions?

 

I ask that because if say were talking about a TV station in say Oklahoma I want to be sure I'm posting in the right area and not posting it in say the Midwest region only to find out it belongs in the south region and vise versa.

 

Thanks

The descriptions of each board will specify the states, based off this map.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Follow up question:

 

How do you define a particular market when posting in the appropriate region? For instance, the Springfield, Missouri Market does spill into Arkansas (which is considered to be part of the South) but Missouri is considered to be part of the Midwest? How would that be handled? Would that be handled on a case by case basis or no?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 8 months later...
  • 10 months later...
  • Weeters changed the title to Changes are(n't) Coming (for now) (Updated January 2022)

I have updated the OP with a statement regarding the status of the previously-announced changes, as well as a bit of what's in store for the site's future overall.

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using TVNewsTalk you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.